Mr Crispy's Pizza Menu (Update 2025)

Mr Crispy's Pizza, located in Garnerville, NY, offers a diverse menu featuring appetizers like Cheese Fries and Garlic Parmesan Fries, Calzones & Stromboli, Gourmet Wraps, and specialty slices. The standout item, according to reviews, is the hero sandwiches, particularly the chicken parm served in a perfect portion size at a competitive price. The sandwiches are toasted to perfection, giving a nice crunch and char to the bread. The shredded chicken and well-balanced cheese and sauce make for a satisfying meal. Customers praise the friendly staff, reasonable prices, and delicious garlic knots. The cozy atmosphere and quick service add to the overall dining experience. If you're in the mood for thin crust pizza or classic Italian dishes like pasta fagioli, Mr Crispy's is a must-visit spot for a hearty and tasty meal.